🔗 Share this article

Accepting the need for change

Ruben Amorim's preferred three-at-the-back system cannot be blamed entirely of Manchester United's difficulties. The club are rebuilding after decades of mismanagement and the present roster remains in transition, with strengths in some areas while obvious flaws continue elsewhere.

However, tactical weaknesses are present in the current tactical approach, most notably underloads in central areas and flank vulnerabilities that require immediate attention. Previous managers have effectively handled comparable situations – Antonio Conte with Chelsea and the Austrian coach with the Eagles show that positional flexibility outweighs pre-match setups.

United's coach recently declared: "The system isn't the problem, our performances are," which resembles addressing consequences while ignoring underlying problems. Opposing teams have repeatedly targeted the same weaknesses in the Red Devils' system for nearly a year, not due to tactical ignorance but because the system itself has fundamental issues.

Consequently, fans shouldn't expect an instant solution where the system suddenly works, similar to expensive signings won't automatically solve the underlying issues. Brentford's recent performance serves as an ideal illustration – although they lost their manager and important squad members during the summer transfer window, they adjusted their formation specifically to exploit Amorim's unchanged tactics.

During the Dutch manager's joined Manchester United, it became apparent that Eredivisie success wouldn't translate to the English top flight; his refusal to modify proved decisive in his final downfall. Presently United's coach – who appears to possess all the necessary qualities for football's toughest job apart from adaptability – is repeating similar errors and squandering a golden opportunity. After many years United maintains owners focused on securing victories rather than profit generation.

Adjusting the outside centre-backs

Wide central defenders play crucial roles in United's formation: they carry possession forward, make important tackles, cover wide areas, change direction, start offensive moves and augment forward play. Any observer could question whether utilizing a pair of such multi-functional defenders in a defensive trio proves logical when a back four could alleviate midfield issues.

Currently, these centre-backs remain constrained by rival forwards who, via basic movement, hinder them from advancing into midfield as the tactics demand. This circumstance enables teams with numerical superiority to circumvent the middle third, generating immediate issues that demand solutions.

Possible solutions include instructing centre-backs to advance regardless – though this risks vulnerability at the back – or withdrawing the attacker to improve build-up play, sacrificing attacking threat but exploiting his driving runs. The smartest modification involves changing the high-press system from the current aggressive setup to a traditional midfield four that offers improved protection and avoids the necessity for defenders to advance.

Reintegrating Kobbie Mainoo

Amorim's preferred style of impatient attacking demands that United abandon midfield control and rely on long balls, banking on exceptional quality rather than organized offensive moves. While statistical metrics suggest improvement, match observations show that recent scoring opportunities stem largely from spot-kick decisions and low-probability efforts rather than consistent attacking.

Top-level teams dominate games through pace control. United's inability to do this isn't completely attributable on Amorim's approach; rumors claim he requested new midfielders during the offseason but encountered resistance from management hierarchy. Beyond fault allocation, the present circumstance cannot continue.

The regular central duo of Casemiro and Bruno Fernandes, with Manuel Ugarte providing cover, has restricted chances for the academy graduate. Despite valid reservations exist about his strength progression and attacking contribution, excluding such talent creates doubts about the approach's validity.

The preferred central trio personify high-tempo football, whereas Mainoo offers rhythm variation. At Sporting Lisbon, his side could play direct football due to quality superiority against Portuguese league defenses, confident they would regain control if they lost it. However in the Premier League, the standard throughout means poor retention receives instant retribution, while pure power exclusively won't secure results.

Mainoo's technical quality stands out, and although combining him with Fernandes creates defensive concerns, such deficiencies prove less important in a controlling side. Considering the team's concession rate showing they concede superior scoring situations than all competitors, integrating Mainoo looks logical to test as different methods have already failed. Although questions persist about his precise contribution in the current setup, consistent minutes represents the ideal improvement method and probably wouldn't damage the current situation.

Improving wing effectiveness

On United's right side, the combination of the Ivorian and Cameroonian could prove effective given their shared attributes of vision, awareness and tenacity. When partnered with the young French defender, they might create an effective combination that improves creative output. At present though, static movement makes marking straightforward for organized defenses.

United's coach should install structured rotation patterns that generate confusion through regular movement. Service into wide areas should vary considerably – not always to feet but frequently ahead of runners to enhance offensive flow. This approach enables inward movement, bypassing opponents and creating passing lanes for scoring opportunities or assists.

Down the left side, Patrick Dorgu often obtains possession in advanced areas despite lacking the technical refinement to utilize productively. Modifying his role somewhat further back would employ his recovery skills and driving runs to {supply more creative players|service better attackers|provide for